Links

Blog Archives

Monthly Archive

ResourcesCounter Blog    
Surface Fabrication and Design Expo

Current Articles | Categories | Search | Syndication

Saturday, August 23, 2008
Product Review: Betterly Stacc-Vac
By Andy @ 9:11 PM :: 403 Views :: 8 Comments :: :: All, Product Review
 

Back in April, Mr. Tom Stoffel, President of Betterly Tools, offered to send a Betterly Coving Router and a Betterly Stacc-Vac Router Base to a fabricator for review. I took him up on his offer.

I felt like a kid on Christmas morning opening presents when I unboxed the Stacc-Vac base at Dani Homrich’s shop in Rochester, Michigan. I’ve seen quality tools before, but this is just ridiculous. The shiny aluminum router base is beckoning me to hurry. The vac hose is extremely high quality black plastic, very supple and firm yet perfectly flexible. The Asians better pray Betterly doesn’t move from Minnesota to Detroit and start making cars. This is how things used to be made here in the states.

I chucked a ¾” roundover bearing bit into the 3 ¼ h/p. Porter Cable router and twisted it into the S/V Base. Combined, this is a heavy unit and a bit unwieldy. I’m sure one would get used to it. I didn’t have to use the new provided vac hose as my Festool vac hose fit the base nipple perfectly. I plugged the router into the Festool vac so when I hit the router switch they both came on simultaneously.

 

 

After Dani shot that video, I remembered that I had forgotten to install the dust deflector on the base bottom which covers the bit and would have allowed even less dust to escape. Betterly claims that for every three ounces of dust on the floor, you’ll suck nearly eight pounds of dust into the vac. Watching the video, I don’t think that’s sales hype.

The weight of the machine that I was just complaining about was helpful in making an excellent edge profile. The large base makes for easy control. I did a shallow and a finished pass, with a well-worn bit each time and the resulting edge was CNC quality. I’ll bet a single pass would produce the same results. I didn’t see a plunge style S/V base in the catalog, hopefully that’s next.

Fig. 1   
Not all fabrication happens at the shop. Some of us who do repairs in homes and restaurants after hours have to keep dust and chips to the absolute minimum. I have a Festool OF2000E/1 router with a plastic dust collector. I broke the plastic nipple off the dust collector the first time I tried to inset it onto the base! I repaired it but the weight of the hose put on too much strain and it eventually failed. With its usual impeccable service, Festool sent me a replacement, but the hose weight is still too great, you really have to baby it. If it fails on a repair job, it’s game over for the night, pack ‘em up, go home and reschedule. This is one rare time when I find the engineering and quality of a Festool product wanting.

Your vac hose isn’t going to budge the Stacc-Vac aluminum nipple; it will follow compliantly like it should. If you back over this thing with your truck, I’m betting you’re going to need to get a flat fixed.

These are all the chips on the floor (Fig. 1) after profiling three linear feet of ½" bullnose edge without the dust deflector installed.

Betterly tools aren’t cheap, but if you spend the money, it’s nice to know you’ve bought the best available anywhere at any price.

About the Author:  Joseph Corlett has over fourteen years experience in the solid surface industry and has written for Surface Fabrication magazine, Slippery Rock Gazette and Old House Journal. You can contact Corlett at loosedeckcannon@comcast.net

Comments
By Norm W. @ Sunday, August 24, 2008 7:13 AM
Joe, how big of a bit will that take (wing width)?
Also, what's up with the duct tape on the vac hose, ya know those cuffs come off the end and you can screw the hose back in the cuff.

By Tom M @ Sunday, August 24, 2008 1:34 PM
Joe,
I always enjoy your reviews. Thanks for posting this, Andy. It may be worth looking into, thanks to Joe.

By Kowboy @ Sunday, August 24, 2008 4:10 PM
Norm:
I don't have the base in front of me, but I'll bet it will take a 3" cutter. I knew someone would notice the duct tape. I've never had much luck screwing those things back in.

Joe

By Kowboy @ Sunday, August 24, 2008 4:27 PM
Norm:
The picture in the video shows a 3/4" cutter and it's clearing the hole by at least a 1/4", so I'm revising my previous estimate.

If you wanted to use a larger bit, I would make a 1/2" MDF sub base, attach it, chuck in the bit clear of the base and fire that mother up. Twist the router upward until the bit cuts the MDF to the depth you want without cutting into the original base.

Oh yeah, don't forget to clamp that base to a bench before firing that thing up and twisting. Saftey first.

Joe

By Jon @ Monday, August 25, 2008 6:06 AM
Nice job Joe! I loved how you added some video to your article. I felt like I was watching This old house

By Refresh Gene @ Monday, August 25, 2008 3:22 PM
I said it before I want one and Im gettin one!!! Joe you da man...great host of a review...you should be Stac-vac representative...Im only buying cause you showed off its work...thanx again for the tips, been looking for something like this
Id bet that would be great to trim the bowls in

By betterleyt @ Wednesday, August 27, 2008 10:32 PM
Joe, If you are impressed with the dust collection as you tried it, put the dust deflector on - I'm guessing you could route in the living room when your wife isn't home and never get caught. When we design and build tools we have two top priorities, performance and quality - thanks for appreciating this in your review.

There seems to be a few questions about our STACC-VAC Bases but i'll try to keep this short, if you want me to post more details let me know or give us a call. First, we make two different sizes, 6" x 9" for most "shop" size routers and another 7" x 11" (size Joe used) for up to 3-1/4 hp routers. The smaller base takes bits up to 2-1/8" and has an optional sub-base to accept templet guides. The large base accepts bits up to 2-3/8" with the standard sub-base and has optional sub-bases to accept bits up to 3-1/2" or templet guides. We also have a guide and insert bit set-up for rabbeting the deck for the cove stick.

We claim over 95% dust extraction. Our tests were in Solid Surface Material, MDF, Particle board, Plywood, Pine, and Oak. We tested several types of cuts - edge profiles, dado, rabbet, straight bit with templet guide following a straight edge, top bearing bit on solid surface, etc. Average for all materials and cuts is well over 95% of the material removed is collected in the vac.

By Andy @ Monday, September 08, 2008 6:08 PM
Joe,

Was Dani the camera man in the video?

You must be logged in to post a comment. You can login here
Syndicate  


 
Domain Industries - FREE Catalog
Nelson Wood Shims
Wesley Tools - Router Bits, Blades and Tools
www.bruceadhesives


  Home|Forum|Resources|"GREEN" Zone|Contact
Copyright 2004-2008 by Karben Copy LLC. All rights reserved. Terms Of Use Privacy Statement